Nobody glues up the spine before rounding and it shows
I picked up a rebound 1908 hymnal at an estate sale in Omaha two weeks ago and the spine had that hollow crack sound when you open it. Turns out the guy who did it skipped the glue-up before rounding, so the signatures just slid around instead of forming a solid block. I've now seen this same mistake on four books from different sellers and every one of them falls apart at the hinge within a year or two. Anyone else noticing this shortcut getting passed off as normal practice lately?
Read a post on a bookbinding forum a while back where a guy said this started when a few shops began rushing batch work to meet online order volume. The glue-up step takes time and clamping, so skipping it speeds up the whole job. Problem is the book looks fine on the shelf until you open it a few dozen times. That hollow crack you heard is the sound of it failing early. Four books from four sellers with the same flaw means it's not bad luck anymore, it's a habit spreading.